Natural nail polishes: non-toxic or just 3-free?
Recently, I bought some nail polishes from Zoya and I was surprised to learn that the brand is considered as natural. I never knew! Actually, it’s not surprising considering that I’ve always favored OPI nail polishes and hence, have never looked at the legions of other brands in the market. However, this is changing because this year, I am keenly seeking more natural alternatives for my nails and my first find was the Karma Organic non-toxic nail polishes. In fact, it was that first find that spurred me to check out if there is such a thing as a natural nail polish.
Free of carcinogenic ingredients
Like I’ve mentioned, even though the Karma Organic nail polishes are said to be natural, they still smell like normal nail polishes to me. What I know is that they are 3-free, which means the nail polishes are free of Toluene, Formaldehyde, and Dibutyl Phthalate (DBP) and it seems that most so-called natural nail polishes are in the same category. These three are widely considered as carcinogenic ingredients and hence, are supposedly bad for health and particularly should be avoided by pregnant or nursing mothers.
Science of 3-Free
In brief, Toluene is a solvent that was used in many nail polish formulations to dissolve other ingredients and make a nice smooth, easy-to-apply polish. Formaldehyde, or more precisely tosylamide formaldehyde resin ensures that the polish adheres to the nail’s surface to make the polish tough and resilient. Finally, DBP acts as a binder and improves the durability and the ability of nail polish to last a long time without chipping. Persephone Magazine has a good article on the Science of “3 Free” Nail Polish if you want to find out more about the characteristics of these three ingredients and the harms they can cause.
Possibly less toxic with less chemicals
In my own opinion, you can’t call a nail polish natural just because they do not contain these three ingredients as the nail polish can still be laced with many other chemicals. I mean, if they smell like paint, then they are not natural to me. But perhaps, they are less toxic than the usual as they may contain less chemicals commonly found in regular nail polish.
Water-based and not solvent-based
What I did find out is that some of the brands of nail polishes that call themselves natural or even vegan are water-based and not solvent-based since they do not use toluene and typically, this means they should not smell as nasty as the usual nail polishes. On top of that, some of them are free of camphor, xylene, and even artificial colors but use only FDA approved colorants or natural colorings. They still use a small amount of plastic, usually in the form of co-polymers but in essence, this group of nail polishes marketed as â€œnaturalâ€ minimize use of synthetic ingredients and chemicals. Some even claim to be hypoallergenic and hence, would not cause irritations to the skin or nails.
Safer to use
So in comparison, these group of nail polishes are odor free, non-toxic, biodegradable, and safe for pregnant women to use. Unlike chemical-based traditional polish, they are said not to cause cancer, birth defects, reproductive issues, allergies, or yellow, discolored nails. So as a whole, they are touted as great for people with chemical sensitivities, allergies, and those who are not currently using nail polish due to harmful chemicals and vapors. Colors could be limited though, compared to the usual brands.
Examples of more natural nail polishes
I found a couple of nail polishes marketed as “natural” and here are examples of their ingredients for an idea:
Main ingredients: Aqua (water, ~65% in formula), acrylate copolymer / styrene-acrylate copolymer (~28% in formula) Other ingredients (all under 4%): propylene glycol n-butyl ether, dipropylene glycol dibenzoate
Pigments/colorant: may contain [+/-] mica (CI 77019), titanium dioxide (CI 77891), ferric ferrocyanide, iron oxide (CI 77491, CI 77492, CI 77499), chromium oxide (CI 77288), carmine (CI 75470)
Ingredients: Acrylic polymer emulsion, Water, and non-toxic colorants (No FD&C). DOES NOT contain Formaldehyde or Formaldehyde like derivatives, Toluene, Ketones or other petrochemical solvents, Dibutyl Phthalate (DBP) or other phthalates, Polyurethanes, Parabens, Camphor, Gluten or wheat by-products, or any aromatic hydrocarbons.
Ingredients: Water, water-miscible acrylic, polyurethane formers and thickeners, non-ionic soaps. May contain: ultramarine blue, carmine, mica, iron oxides, and/or titanium dioxide.
May be harder to remove
As you can see, some of them are more natural than the others. And it should be noted that while these contain less chemicals, there are some reports that such natural nail polishes are not as lasting or that they are harder to remove. This is particularly so because the film that is formed by the water-based system becomes more difficult to dissolve as time passes. I also found out that if they’re water based, they might be less likely to thicken and if they should thicken, then we should be using water to dilute the polish instead.
OPI is 3-free since 2008
Anyway, I read randomly from many sites that OPI is a 3-Free brand since 2008. How you can identify an OPI with the 3-Free formula is by the green lettering on the label. Bottles with black text have the old formula. So my new “The One That Got Away” under the Kate Perry OPI collection is completely 3-Free while my old “SOHO Nice To Meet You” is not. Well, I certainly didn’t know anything about this back in 2002/2003 when I was pregnant and then nursing. I just used whatever were in my stash and then, all my OPIs had the black lettering labels! And my boy is fine, thank you very much! (#k8SjZc9Dxk-#k8SjZc9Dxk)
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
I recently acquired a Zoya polish and the lacquer smell is exceptionally strong. Even stronger than those no-brand ones I own.
Using Honeybee Gardens nail polishes & remover occasionally. They have lovely shades, easy to apply. At least 2 coats needed, otherwise it’ll chip easily. It still chips more easily than OPI. Removal is easy with their remover though. No funky smells with the nail polish.
Yeah, agree. It’s not as strong as OPI’s but still strong.
Oh you’ve tried Honeybee Gardens’ nail polishes? Their ingredients look pretty good.
Has anyone tried these ones from Scotch Naturals? See here http://www.scotchnaturals.com/
Apparently the only ingredients are: water, acrylic polymer emulsion, and non toxic colorants.
They are so beautiful, but haven’t been albe to buy one yet here in Europe. They also have a line for kids.
I know the online store of Challenger — yes, the Challenger of IT and electronic products! — sells some brands of non-toxic kids’ nail polishes too. The “Hopscotch” line under scotchnaturals mentioned by Ozana above is also there. Guess “non-toxic” kids’ brands would be a safer option for adults too? Think they are having 40% off some items now, under “Kids” and “Accessories” for those who are interested ?
OMG! Butter London!!! I was about to order it online from an overseas store thinking it’s not available here. Oh much thanks!!! Shall check and probably order soon. ?
I’ve seen these around…the packaging is really nice.
Thanks for this article! I have sworn off nail polish since I had had my first kid because I don’t want to expose them to toxic chemicals but now perhaps I will give these a try.
I LOVE LOVE LOVE Butter London. It’s 3 free and it goes on really smooth. I find that it lasts longer than my other polishes as well. You should def try it!!
They have amazing colors as well.
I think those that are 3-free are safer and can be considered. Best to use those without the nasty smell if you have health concerns.
Yeah, I will give it a try soon. Can’t wait to order. ?
What about Priti? Is water baased or just 3free? Today I was attempt to buy a china Glaze, but when I read It has the big 3! And I just read on the web is was 3 free…
Free of Toxic Trio isnâ€™t enough for some brands. Snails (safe nails) is 6-free
DIBUTYL PHTHALTE (DBP)
First WASHABLE (no acetone required to remove) nail polish made in France
Be careful of calling anything chemical free, as natural. Everything including our own bodies are made of chemicals, the only thing not chemical free is a vaccum like space. same with “natural” formaldehyde even occurs in nature, making it “natural” natural and chemical are both buzz words which instill fear in people unneccassarily. however I do agree that avoiding the big 3 chemicals is smart and healthier therer are less toxic chemical to use. just be careful of terminology so you are not using buzz words please.